top of page

ProtonMail vs. Tutanota

Which Secure Email Service is Best?


ProtonMail and Tutanota Secure Private Email

In the ever-expanding digital landscape, ensuring the security and privacy of your online communications has become paramount. ProtonMail and Tutanota have emerged as two of the best private email services you can get in 2024, promising cutting-edge encryption and unwavering dedication to user privacy. In this blog post, we will conduct a detailed side-by-side comparison of ProtonMail and Tutanota, exploring their security measures, privacy policies, unique features, pricing, and more, to help you make an informed decision on which service is better suited for your specific needs.


Security and Privacy:


ProtonMail and Tutanota share a common foundation of end-to-end encryption, where even the service providers themselves cannot access your email content. Tutanota takes pride in its extensive encryption coverage, encrypting subject lines, email bodies, and attachments with RSA 2048-bit and AES 128-bit protocols. ProtonMail, on the other hand, relies on AES 256-bit encryption, recognized as the gold standard in cryptography, but does not encrypt subject lines. Both services guarantee that they never compromise on encryption, ensuring the utmost security for your messages.

Anonymity and Data Jurisdiction:


To safeguard user anonymity, Tutanota and ProtonMail go to great lengths. Tutanota strips IP addresses from messages, making it extremely challenging for anyone to trace back the communication to the user. ProtonMail shares a similar commitment to anonymity, and its servers are securely tucked away in a former military bunker under a kilometer of granite, providing exceptional physical protection against potential attacks.


However, it's worth noting that ProtonMail, despite its robust privacy measures, had to comply with Swiss government requests to hand over IP addresses in a criminal investigation case in 2021. In Switzerland, like in many other countries, businesses are obligated to comply with lawful requests from government authorities, particularly in criminal investigations.


Privacy Laws and Jurisdiction:


Tutanota, based in Germany, operates under the jurisdiction of the "Fourteen Eyes" alliance. The "14 Eyes" alliance is a network of countries that collaboratively share intelligence and conduct surveillance activities. Being part of this alliance raises concerns for some individuals who value online privacy, as it can potentially lead to data sharing and surveillance among member countries. However, its users' data is protected by the stringent German Federal Data Protection Act (BDSG), which prohibits the use or collection of personal data without explicit consent.


ProtonMail's headquarters are located in Switzerland, known for its strong privacy laws and neutrality. The Swiss Federal Act on Data Protection (FADP) ensures that data processing requires explicit consent, enhancing user privacy. While both services prioritize privacy, the Swiss jurisdiction offers a unique advantage to ProtonMail.


Learn more about 5, 9, and 14 Eyes Alliances


Spam Filtering:


Spam filtering is an essential aspect of secure email services. Tutanota offers an intelligent spam filter, but some users have found it to be overly restrictive. On the other hand, ProtonMail employs a smart spam detection system, automatically categorizing incoming messages into the inbox or spam folder. While ProtonMail's system works efficiently, there have been instances of misplacing legitimate emails.


Features:


ProtonMail stands out with its ProtonVPN integration, offering an additional layer of security and privacy for its users. Moreover, ProtonMail Bridge enables seamless integration with various third-party email clients, providing greater flexibility. On the other hand, Tutanota offers its unique feature called SecureConnect, which allows users to embed Tutanota's security into website contact forms, catering to businesses that prioritize secure communication with their customers.


When it comes to storage, ProtonMail offers more significant storage options than Tutanota. ProtonMail's paid plans can go up to 500GB, while Tutanota limits its paid storage to 10GB. This difference can be a deciding factor for users who require ample storage for their emails and attachments.


Pricing:


If budget-friendliness is a priority, Tutanota stands out as the more economical choice. Its free plan provides 1GB of storage, twice as much as ProtonMail's free plan, which offers 500MB of storage. When it comes to premium plans, Tutanota generally offers more affordable options compared to ProtonMail.


Tutanota's premium plans include the Personal plan, priced at €1.2 per month or €12 annually, offering additional features and storage. For businesses or users with more extensive needs, Tutanota offers the Teams plan at €4 per month, and the Pro plan at €7 per month, catering to different requirements and team sizes.


On the other hand, ProtonMail's premium plans come with added benefits. The Professional plan, priced at €7.99 per month, offers 5GB of storage, custom domains, and priority customer support. The Visionary plan, priced at €30 per month, provides 20GB of storage, as well as ProtonVPN Plus with access to 10 simultaneous connections and other exclusive features.


Device Support and User-Friendliness:


Both ProtonMail and Tutanota are user-friendly and offer web versions, desktop clients for various operating systems, and mobile apps. However, ProtonMail gains an edge with its seamless integration with popular third-party email clients, making it more versatile for users who prefer using different email interfaces.


Customer support is essential, especially when dealing with security and privacy concerns. Tutanota offers email support to paid users, while ProtonMail extends email support to both free and paid users. Additionally, both providers have comprehensive knowledge bases and active Reddit communities.


Verdict:


In the realm of secure email services, both ProtonMail and Tutanota are formidable contenders, each excelling in different areas. ProtonMail's strong integration with ProtonVPN and third-party clients provides enhanced features for advanced users. On the other hand, Tutanota's affordability, extensive encryption coverage, and SecureConnect feature cater to users seeking a budget-friendly and business-oriented email service.


Ultimately, the choice between ProtonMail and Tutanota hinges on your specific requirements and preferences. Whichever option you select, both services offer unparalleled security and privacy, ensuring that your sensitive communications remain shielded from prying eyes in today's digitally interconnected world. Remember to complement your secure email usage with other cybersecurity measures like a reliable VPN for comprehensive online protection.



Read our article about the Best VPNs for 2024 to learn more.



**NomadPrep contains affiliate links and will be compensated for purchases made after clicking these links.

Comments


Commenting has been turned off.
bottom of page